11 min read 2,059 words

Sludge halls in the chemical and wastewater industries harbor an often underestimated danger: sewage sludge continuously outgasses methane (CH₄). Under unfavorable ventilation conditions, the CH₄ concentration can locally reach safety-critical levels. Since the lower explosive limit (LEL) of methane is as low as 4.4 vol.%, reliable, continuous methane monitoring is indispensable – as a core requirement of GefStoffV, BetrSichV, and the relevant technical rules TRGS 720 and TRBS 2152 Part 1/TRGS 721 (Hazardous explosive atmospheres). In this article, we demonstrate how Fresenius Umwelttechnik implements such safety-relevant CH₄ monitoring in a sludge hall – and why the choice of measurement principle determines whether you get reliability or a false alarm.

Initial Situation: Sewage Sludge Atmosphere as a Measurement Challenge

In the sludge hall of our application case, several unfavorable factors come together: high humidity, dust, fluctuating temperatures up to 50°C in the sample gas, and a complex gas matrix of CH₄, H₂S, CO₂ and O₂. The area is classified as an Ex zone in accordance with the ATEX Directive 2014/34/EU and the EN 60079 series of standards.

At first glance, the measurement task appears simple: detect methane in the range of 0–10 vol.% so that alarms can be reliably triggered below the LEL. In practice, however, selectivity and long-term stability determine whether an analyzer provides resilient values in continuous operation – or becomes a risk due to cross-sensitivity and sensor poisoning.

Why NDIR instead of pellistor? Safety through selectivity

Classic pellistor sensors (catalytic bead) are widely used in industrial gas warning systems. However, in a sludge hall atmosphere, they reach their physical limits:

  • H₂S poisoning: Hydrogen sulfide leads to deactivation of the catalytic element and thus to systematically low measured values – a critical safety risk for LEL monitoring.
  • Silicone and siloxane exposure: Sewage sludge emissions often contain siloxanes, which irreversibly damage the pellistor and drastically shorten its service life.
  • Oxygen deficiency: Pellistors require O₂ for catalytic combustion. If the oxygen content drops below approximately 10–15 vol.%, the signal falls – even though methane is still present.
  • Non-specificity: A pellistor detects any combustible gas – it cannot distinguish methane from other hydrocarbons, which can lead to false alarms.

Non-dispersive infrared spectroscopy (NDIR) structurally avoids these weaknesses. Methane characteristically absorbs infrared radiation at around 3.3 µm – a wavelength range in which neither H₂S nor CO₂ exhibit dominant absorption bands. Using a dual-beam approach with a reference channel at a non-absorbing wavelength, the methane signal is corrected for drift and matrix effects. The result is a selective, poison-free CH₄ measurement that remains stable even in atmospheres containing H₂S and CO₂.

Our Solution: GA210 with Adapted LEL Measuring Range

For this application, we use the Gas Analyzer GA210 from Fresenius Umwelttechnik in LEL version with NDIR dual-beam technology. Instead of a standard measuring range up to 100% by volume, the analyzer is optimized for 0–10% by volume CH₄ – precisely the safety-relevant range around the LEL of 4.4% by volume. Thanks to the optimized measuring cell geometry and adapted characteristic curve evaluation, resolution and accuracy are fully available in the critical window.

Parameter Design
Measured component CH₄ (Methane)
Measuring range 0–10 vol.%
Measurement principle NDIR dual-beam with reference detector
Resolution 0.1 vol.%
Detection limit 0.5 vol.%
Measurement uncertainty ≤ 3% of the measured value
Response time (Tₐ₀, analyzer) approx. 3 s
Measurement interval Every second (continuous)
Pressure compensation 0.7–1.1 bar abs.
Measuring cell Temperature-stabilized at 45°C
Cross-sensitivity None towards H₂S and CO₂
Sample gas pump Internal, approx. 4 l/min
Analog output 4–20 mA (PLC integration)
Zero point adjustment 1× daily, approx. 2 min, automatic with ambient air

Response Time: Is an Extractive System Fast Enough for LEL Monitoring?

With extractive measurement systems – i.e. systems in which the sample gas is transported to the analyzer via a sampling line – the question rightly arises: Is the overall response time sufficient for safety-relevant LEL monitoring? The answer results from three factors.

Factor 1: The Dynamics of Methane Increase in the Hall Volume

Sludge halls typically have a room volume of several hundred to several thousand cubic meters. Even in the event of a sudden outgassing event, the CH₄ concentration in the hall volume rises relatively slowly – dilution in the large room volume acts as a natural damper. In practice, an increase from ambient level to the pre-alarm threshold of 0.88% by volume (20% LEL) takes minutes, not seconds. The key question is therefore not whether the analyzer responds in 3 or 30 seconds – but whether the overall system reliably detects the increase in concentration before a critical level is reached.

Factor 2: Fast Gas Transport via High-Performance Pump

The internal sample gas pump of the GA210 delivers approx. 4 l/min – a comparatively high volume flow for an analyzer of this class. Even with the maximum line length of 40 m using PTFE tubing (4 mm inner diameter), the pure transport time of the gas from the sampling point to the analyzer is only a few seconds. Together with the analyzer Tₐ₀ of approx. 3 seconds, this results in a system response time that is well under 30 seconds, even with the maximum line path.

Factor 3: Normative Classification – EN 60079-29-1

EN 60079-29-1 defines the requirements for the operating behavior of gas measuring devices for flammable gases. The required Tₐ₀ time for the analyzer is ≤ 30 seconds. For comparison: pellistor sensors installed directly in the hall – i.e. without any sampling line – have typical Tₐ₀ times of 10–30 seconds. The extractive GA210 system achieves a comparable or even better overall response time even with 40 m of line – while offering the decisive advantages of NDIR technology: selectivity, H₂S resistance and long-term stability.

Conclusion on response time: The extractive system concept is not only fast enough for LEL monitoring in sludge halls, it comfortably exceeds the normative requirements. The few seconds of transport time are offset by a real safety gain that cannot be achieved with an in-situ pellistor in an H₂S-containing atmosphere.

Ex Protection Without an ATEX Analyzer: The Extractive System Concept

The GA210 is a precision analyzer for climate-controlled technical rooms (ideally 15–25°C ambient temperature). It does not have ATEX device certification and is therefore consistently installed outside the Ex zone. The sludge hall itself remains free of measurement devices – sampling is performed extractively.

Our System Architecture:

  • Sampling probe in the sludge hall with a coarse filter.
  • ATEX-certified inline flame arrester (EN ISO 16852) at the transition from the Ex zone to the safe area. It reliably prevents flame or ignition flashback.
  • PTFE sample gas line with lengths up to 40 m. For humid sample gases, we additionally recommend a self-limiting sample gas trace heating system, which maintains the gas above the dew point and reliably prevents condensation.
  • Universal sample gas filter (5 µm PTFE membrane) immediately upstream of the analyzer to protect against residual dust and aerosols.
  • Climate-controlled technical room at 15–25°C, where the GA210 can be operated stably.

This concept cleanly separates measurement technology and the hazardous area – a foundation for plants operated according to GefStoffV § 6 and BetrSichV §§ 15/16.

Sample Gas Conditioning as the Key to Long-Term Stability

In a humid, dusty atmosphere, it is not the analyzer alone but the sample gas conditioning that determines the availability of the overall system.

Condensate Management

If moisture condenses in the line, droplets form that cause pulsations and measured value fluctuations. Optional trace heating of the PTFE line keeps the gas continuously above the dew point. If required, a gas cooler with condensate separator can also be used.

Particle Retention

Dust from the sludge hall must never enter the NDIR measuring cell. We recommend a two-stage setup: a probe filter (approx. 100 µm) at the sampling point and the universal sample gas filter (5 µm) directly upstream of the analyzer. Maintenance intervals: quarterly inspection, semi-annual filter replacement.

Pressure Adjustment

The applied sample gas pressure must be brought into the analyzer’s compensation range (0.7–1.1 bar abs.). If sample gas pressures are outside this range, the inlet pressure can be stabilized via flow resistances, bypass routing or active pressure control.

Redundancy: Two Devices for Seamless Safety Monitoring

An occupational safety measurement in the LEL range must not allow any monitoring gaps – not even during the daily automatic zero calibration. For safety-relevant applications, we therefore recommend a redundant design with two analyzers. While one device runs its calibration (approx. 2 minutes), the second takes over measurement seamlessly. This concept significantly increases availability and also allows plausibility checking of the measured values during operation.

The 4–20 mA analog outputs of both devices can be connected to the higher-level safety PLC, including pre-alarm and main alarm thresholds – typically at 20% LEL (0.88% by volume CH₄) and 40% LEL (1.76% by volume CH₄). If exceeded, ventilation measures are activated automatically or processes are stopped.

Standards and Regulations: Legally Compliant Implementation

The design and operation of methane monitoring systems in sludge halls and comparable areas of the chemical industry are subject to strict legal requirements:

  • TRGS 720: Hazardous explosive atmospheres – General aspects.
  • TRBS 2152 Part 1 / TRGS 721: Hazardous explosive atmospheres – Assessment of the explosion hazard.
  • BetrSichV §§ 15/16: Testing of systems requiring monitoring before commissioning and recurringly.
  • GefStoffV § 6: Information gathering and risk assessment for activities involving hazardous substances.
  • EN 60079-29-1: Gas detectors – Performance requirements of detectors for flammable gases.
  • EN ISO 16852: Flame arresters – Performance requirements, test methods and limits for use.
  • ATEX Directive 2014/34/EU: Equipment and protective systems intended for use in potentially explosive atmospheres.

Fresenius Umwelttechnik supports you in the risk assessment and the creation of the explosion protection document in accordance with GefStoffV/BetrSichV. Please feel free to contact us!

Safety is a System Topic – Not Just a Sensor Topic

Reliable CH₄ monitoring in a sludge hall only succeeds if the measurement principle, sampling, sample gas conditioning and system integration are considered as a single unit. NDIR technology with targeted wavelength selection at 3.3 µm provides the selective, poison-free methane measurement that pellistor systems cannot deliver in H₂S-containing atmospheres. The combination of inline flame arrester, sampling line up to 40 m and air-conditioned technical room enables safe operation of the analyzer outside the Ex zone. The extractive concept is not slower than in-situ pellistor systems – with significantly higher measurement safety. And a redundant two-device concept ensures that monitoring is never interrupted, even during the daily zero calibration.

At Fresenius Umwelttechnik, we accompany our customers from risk assessment and sampling design to commissioning and long-term service. If you are planning resilient LEL monitoring for your sludge hall or a comparable application in the chemical industry, contact us – we will work with you to develop a concept that meets both normative requirements and your plant reality.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Why is NDIR better than pellistor for methane in sludge halls?

NDIR sensors are selective for methane at a wavelength of 3.3 µm and are not affected by H₂S, siloxanes or oxygen deficiency. Pellistors can be poisoned by H₂S, require oxygen and are non-specific to flammable gases.

Which alarm thresholds are common for LEL monitoring?

Pre-alarm at 20% LEL (0.88% by volume CH₄) and main alarm at 40% LEL (1.76% by volume CH₄). If exceeded, ventilation measures are activated or processes are stopped.

Does the gas analyzer have to be ATEX-certified?

Not with extractive sampling. The analyzer is installed outside the Ex zone. An ATEX-certified inline flame arrestor (EN ISO 16852) at the zone transition is decisive.

How often does the GA210 need to be calibrated?

The GA210 automatically performs a zero point adjustment with ambient air once a day – duration approx. 2 minutes, fully automatic or externally triggerable via PLC. Additionally, we recommend a regular span gas check – the interval depends on operational safety requirements.

Is the extractive system fast enough for LEL monitoring?

Yes. The analyzer Tₐ₀ is approx. 3 seconds. Even with a 40 m sampling line and the powerful internal pump (4 l/min), the system response time remains well under 30 seconds – thus comfortably meeting the requirements of EN 60079-29-1. For comparison: in-situ pellistor sensors have typical Tₐ₀ times of 10–30 seconds but offer no selectivity and no H₂S resistance.

What sample gas conditioning is necessary?

Essential: PTFE sample gas line (up to 40 m), two-stage filtration (probe filter + sample gas filter) and ATEX flame arrester. For high humidity, we recommend sample gas trace heating. Optionally, a sample gas cooler with condensate separator can be used.

How quickly does the system react to a methane increase?

In a large-volume sludge hall, the CH₄ concentration rises over minutes, not seconds, even in the event of a sudden outgassing event. The system response time of the GA210 extractive system is a few seconds up to a maximum of approx. 20 seconds (with 40 m line) – meaning the system detects an increase in concentration well before a critical level is reached.