10 min read 1,911 words
Why the long-term stability of your infrared analyzer can be worth millions—and how manufacturers differ fundamentally.Anyone operating a biogas plant, a sewage treatment plant or emission monitoring knows the problem: The measured values of the gas analyzer are correct today – but will they still be correct in three months? In six? In a year? The gradual shift in measured values at constant gas concentration is called drift. It is the central quality characteristic that separates good NDIR analyzers from bad ones. In this article, we explain why drift occurs, why it is so expensive in practice – and how Fresenius Umwelttechnik achieves exceptional long-term stability with two different, complementary measurement principles.What is drift—and why is it so insidious? NDIR gas analyzers (Non-Dispersive Infrared) measure gas concentrations by passing infrared radiation through a gas sample and evaluating the wavelength-specific absorption according to the Lambert-Beer law. The principle is physically robust – but the hardware ages. And this is exactly where the problem begins.Drift refers to a systematic, slow shift in the measurement signal that has nothing to do with an actual change in gas concentration. It manifests itself as a gradual increase or decrease in the baseline value over days, weeks and months. Unlike noise, which randomly scatters around a mean value, drift is a directional trend – and therefore particularly dangerous because it is often only noticed by the operator when it has already caused significant measurement errors.The main causes of drift in NDIR systems are: Temperature and pressure fluctuations: Changes in ambient temperature influence the radiation characteristics of the IR source and the sensitivity of the detector. Pressure fluctuations change the gas density in the measuring cell and thus the effective absorption.Aging of the IR source: Every infrared source loses radiation intensity over time. In systems without effective referencing, this loss of intensity directly affects the measurement signal.Degradation of the detector: Pyroelectric detectors change their sensitivity over their operating life. Without a compensation mechanism, another, difficult-to-predict drift source arises.Optical contamination: Dust particles, condensate films and chemical deposits on mirrors, windows and filter surfaces weaken IR transmission. In industrial environments – especially with biogas with high H₂S concentrations – this effect is particularly pronounced.The cost of drift: more than just incorrect numbersIn practice, drift is not an abstract measurement problem – it costs real money and jeopardizes compliance. Some scenarios:Biogas feed-in: When feeding into the natural gas grid, the methane content determines the settlement price. A drift of only 3% on the CH₄ measured value in a plant with a feed-in capacity of 600 Nm³/h leads to systematic billing errors that can add up to five-figure amounts over months.Process control: For process control in biogas plants, a drifted CH₄ or CO₂ measurement means an incorrect assessment of the gas composition. A methane content displayed too low leads to unnecessary interventions, one displayed too high conceals process problems – with direct effects on the economic efficiency of the plant.Calibration and maintenance costs: Systems with higher drift tendency require more frequent calibrations. Test gas cylinders for CH₄, CO₂ and zero gas cost several hundred euros per calibration. With quarterly calibration of a multi-point plant, five-figure sums accumulate over the device’s service life – costs that are eliminated or drastically reduced with a long-term stable measuring system.In all cases: The cost of drift typically exceeds the investment in a long-term stable measurement system by a multiple.Two approaches—one goal: eliminate drift at the source Fresenius Umwelttechnik pursues a clear philosophy in NDIR gas analysis: Drift is not subsequently compensated for by frequent calibration, but is minimized from the outset by the optical and electronic architecture of the device. For this purpose, we use two different, complementary measurement principles depending on the application.Approach 1: Dual-beam NDIR with reference detectorThe dual-beam method (two-beam NDIR) uses an integrated optical beam splitter in the detector housing that evenly distributes the IR light from the source to all measurement channels – for example, the measurement channel for CH₄ and a reference channel. Since both channels use exactly the same light source via the same optical path, all changes – source aging, temperature influences, optical contamination – affect both channels equally. By forming the quotient of the measurement and reference signals, these influences are automatically compensated.Additional features of our dual-beam concept that further improve long-term stability:Power-controlled, thermally stabilized IR source: The radiant intensity is actively controlled and kept constant.Temperature-stabilized and encapsulated measuring chamber: The entire measuring cell is thermally stabilized and shielded from external environmental influences.Proprietary characteristic-curve evaluation: Our mathematical evaluation algorithms also take pronounced nonlinearities of the absorption curve into account—allowing us to precisely capture both very low and very high concentrations with a single calibration curve.Intelligent adaptive signal averaging: The system automatically detects whether a signal change is due to an actual concentration change or whether itwhether it is measurement noise or drift. Only real concentration changes are output as measured values.Zero point adjustment without test gas cylinder: In most applications, activated carbon-filtered ambient air is sufficient for automatic zero point adjustment. Nitrogen is only required in special cases.Calibration interval (dual-beam): 6 to 12 months—depending on the sensitivity of the measurement task and the environmental conditions.Approach 2: The patented two-pressure reference methodThe two-pressure reference method—also known as the vacuum reference method—is based on an elegant physical principle: the gas to be analyzed serves as its own reference.The method runs in two successive measurement phases: In Phase I, the sample gas is at a defined normal pressure (p₁) in the measuring cuvette. The infrared absorption is recorded during this phase. In Phase II, the pressure in the same cuvette is reduced to a significantly lower value (p₂, typically approx. 200 mbar absolute) – by pumping out the gas. As the molecular concentration in the gas decreases with pressure, the absorption also changes. The gas concentration is calculated precisely from the ratio of the two absorption values.The decisive advantage: Because both measurements take place sequentially in the same cuvette with the same emitter and the same detector, all slow changes—source aging, detector drift, contamination of the optical windows—affect both measurements in the same way. When forming the ratio, these influences cancel out completely. The result is outstanding long-term stability: long-term drift of less than 3% per year on the IR measurement channels.No reference gas, no second optical path, no filter changes—the two-pressure method eliminates drift structurally, not through compensation.Calibration interval (two-pressure reference method): Once per year—in practice, often the only external intervention required for precise, compliant measurement.The comparison in figuresCriterionFresenius UmwelttechnikStandard single-beam/two-channel systems*Automatic zero point correctionZeroLock—no test gas, patentedTypically test-gas-basedCalibration interval (NDIR)1× per year3–6 months (manufacturer-dependent)Device service life> 30 years10–15 years (typical)Ongoing test gas costsVirtually zero (no test gas required for the zero point)Ongoing (cylinders, pressure regulators, labor)*The information in the right column describes general market categories and does not refer to a single manufacturer. Specific specifications vary depending on model and configuration. What does this mean in practice?For operators of a biogas plant, a wastewater treatment plant, or a CEMS measuring point, long-term stability translates directly into operational advantages:Less downtime. Each calibration requires an interruption of measurement operation. With systems that only need to be calibrated once a year, downtime is reduced to a minimum.Lower operating costs. Test gas cylinders for CH₄, CO₂ and zero gas cost several hundred euros per calibration. With quarterly calibration of a multi-point plant, five-figure sums accumulate over the device’s service life – costs that are eliminated with a test gas-free zero point adjustment.Reliable compliance. An analyzer that drifts less than 3% over 12 months reliably meets compliance requirements. The uncertainty contributions remain small, which simplifies the entire validation process.Proven longevity: Fresenius Umwelttechnik regularly maintains and recalibrates devices that have been in field use since the 1990s. Spare parts are still available for these devices. A device service life of over 30 years is not a marketing promise, but verifiable practical experience.Better process control. When the CH₄ and CO₂ measured values are correct, the assessment of gas quality is also correct—whether before grid feed-in, for CHP control, or for monitoring fermenter biology.Drift is not a law of natureThe drift of an NDIR gas analyzer is not an unavoidable physical fate. It is the result of design decisions – the chosen optical architecture, thereferencing strategy and the evaluation algorithms. Systems without effective drift compensation buy low acquisition costs with high ongoing calibration and maintenance costs as well as with the risk of significant measurement errors.Fresenius Umwelttechnik takes a different approach: with the dual-beam method with reference detector and the patented two-pressure reference method, our NDIR analyzers achieve long-term stability that significantly exceeds the market standard. Less than 3% drift per year with the two-pressure method, without external test gas for the zero point, with a device service life of more than 30 years—this is not a marketing claim, but the result of more than 175 years of experience in analytical chemistry.If you would like to know how our analyzers perform in your specific application, please contact us. Our measurement technology experts will be pleased to advise you—also on site.Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) What is drift and why does it occur? Drift is a slow, directional shift in the measurement signal that has nothing to do with an actual change in concentration. Causes include, among others, aging of the IR source, changes in detector sensitivity, optical contamination of the measuring cuvette, and temperature and pressure fluctuations.How do the dual-beam and two-pressure reference methods differ? The dual-beam method splits the IR light simultaneously into a measurement and a reference channel and compensates for fluctuations by forming a ratio. It is particularly suitable for multi-component measurements. The two-pressure reference method measures the same gas sequentially at two different pressures in the same cuvette – this eliminates all sources of drift through mutual compensation. An external reference gas is not required. The resulting long-term drift is below 3% per year.How often does a Fresenius NDIR analyzer need to be calibrated? Devices with two-pressure reference method usually only require a single external calibration per year. For dual-beam systems, we recommend an interval of 6 to 12 months depending on the sensitivity of the measurement task. In both cases, the zero point adjustment is automatic – in most applications without a test gas cylinder.What happens if I calibrate my analyzer less frequently? In systems with a higher drift tendency, a skipped calibration can lead to systematic measurement errors – with the described consequences for billing, process control, and economic efficiency. Our devices are designed to remain stable even over longer intervals. Nevertheless, we recommend annual calibration as a quality assurance measure. Is it true that Fresenius devices remain in operation for over 30 years? Yes – and that’s not a marketing claim. Fresenius Umwelttechnik regularly receives devices from the 1990s for annual maintenance and recalibration. Spare parts are still available for these devices. This is the best proof that high investment quality is the more convincing economic decision in the long term.Which applications are your NDIR analyzers suitable for? Our NDIR devices are used, among other things, in biogas plants (CH₄, CO₂, H₂S monitoring), wastewater treatment plants, landfills, industrial processes, and environmental measurement technology. Please contact us—we will recommend the optimal measurement principle and the appropriate device configuration for your specific application.